Fatwas, niqabs and 'acceptable standards': Is conservative Islam on the rise across Indonesia?

Posted by On 1:51 PM

Fatwas, niqabs and 'acceptable standards': Is conservative Islam on the rise across Indonesia?

Email Fatwas, niqabs and 'acceptable standards': Is conservative Islam on the rise across Indonesia?

Updated September 09, 2018 05:14:24

Indonesian's praying in the Muslim faith Photo: Indonesia is the most populous Muslim nation with 87 per cent of its people identifying as Muslims. (Reuters: Roni Bintang) Related Story: Indonesian woman imprisoned after complaining mosque is too loud Related Story: Indonesia's top Islamic body issues fatwa against measles vaccine Related Story : Jakarta's Muslim protesters warned they're being misled by conservatives Related Story: Indonesian President chooses conservative Muslim cleric for running mate Map: Indonesia

In the latest interpretation of Sharia law in Indonesia's Aceh province, it is now "haram" â€" or religiously forbidden â€" for a woman to sit at the same cafe table as a man she is not married or related to.

Key points:

  • Jakarta is the most intolerant city in the country, according to an Indonesian think tank
  • It also found 201 cases of religious freedom violations across the country
  • Indonesia is the largest Muslim society in the world

The local government notice issued in one small Aceh city also advised businesses not to serve women after 9:00pm, unless they were accompanied by a male family member or husband.

Thos e were just two of 14 listed "acceptable standards" for restaurant and cafe patrons, and the latest in a string of events highlighting the rise of Islamic conservatism across the Indonesian archipelago.

Indonesia's long road to democracy

Indonesia's slow and circuitous road to democracy
Significant progress has been made in relation to Indonesia's democratisation over the past 20 years, but a culture of impunity around human rights abuses persists, writes Olivia Nicole Tasevski.

The most notable in recent weeks was the imprisonment of a minority Buddhist ethnic-Chinese woman, known as Meiliana, after she complained about the volume of a mosque's call to prayer.

The country also saw kindergarten students parade in niqabs and fake assault rifles, as well as a fatwa that claimed the life-saving measles vaccine contained haram subst ances.

The list of standards for hospitality businesses was released by a local mayor in Aceh, where Islamic criminal law works hand-in-hand with the largely secular laws of Indonesia.

While not legally binding, it illustrates the entanglement of politics and religion in the country, which some say has been exacerbated by President Joko Widodo's recent appointment of a hard-line Islamic cleric as his 2019 presidential running mate.

So what is happening in one of Australia's closest neighbours? Has it become more conservatively Islamic?

More than 200 cases of religious freedom violations

A crowd gathering in protest Photo: An anti-Ahok crowd gathered outside the courtroom protesting in south Jakarta. (ABC News: Adam Harvey)

The independent Indonesian think tank Setara Institute found Jakarta to be the most religiously intolerant city in the majority Muslim country, with 23 accounts of violations so far this year.

While results from Aceh â€" where shariah law has been introduced â€" have not been released this year, last year's results found West Java and Jakarta were far more intolerant.

Reported incidents included discrimination, assault, hate speech and the sealing of houses of worship for other religious groups â€" as well as a disproportionate impact of blasphemy laws on minority groups.

Jakarta Governor Basuki Tjahaja Purnama. Photo: Ahok was charged with blasphemy in October. (ABC News: Phil Hemingway)

The organisation also found 201 cases of religio us freedom violations across the country's 20 provinces, mostly towards minorities.

Greg Fealy, associate professor at the Australian National University, said there had been a greater frequency of cases of rising conservatism in the past decade.

"We have too many cases of what I would regard as violations of religious freedom of speech, but conservatism somewhat fuels that process," he said.

However, he said it was too complex a matter to simply take a national snapshot based on these events.

Some experts believe the trend started in 2017 during a conservative Islamic-backed movement which saw the removal of Jakarta's former minority Christian governor, Basuku Tjahaja Purnama, more commonly known as Ahok.

Children wearing a burqa and holding cut-out weapons in parade    Photo: Children in East Java province marched in niqabs with fake guns during Independence Day parades. (Detik News)

Bonar Tigor Naipospos, deputy chairman of Setara Institute, said politicising religion was a very effective way to mobilise large numbers of people.

"And Pak Ma'ruf Amin [Mr Widodo's running mate] is one of the main keys to awakening the wave of intolerance in Indonesia," he said.

Muslim-majority, not 'Muslim-country'

Muslim protesters march during a protest against Jakarta's Christian Governor Basuki "Ahok" Tjahaja Purnama. Photo: Muslim protesters march during a protest against Jakarta's Christian Governor Basuki "Ahok". (AP: Achmad Ibrahim)

Indonesia is the largest Muslim society in the world, with 87 per cent of its 270 million people identifying as Muslim.

However religious pluralism and tolerance are considered to be part of Indonesia's five founding principles of Pancasila.

"Indonesia has chosen its own way by choosing Pancasila as a middle road, by stating we are not secular, but we are not a Muslim country," Mr Naipospos said.

But survey data presented by Dr Fealy show middle-class Indonesians are expressing increasingly intolerant views.

"They're the kinds of people who would rather not have a non-Muslim teaching their kids, living beside them or doing business with them," he said.

Widodo's hard-line running mate


Indonesian President Joko Widodo now has a controversial hard-line Muslim cleric as his running mate â€" why?

In 2017, more than half a million people took to the streets of Jakarta in a successful public pressure campaign under the banner of 'defenders of Islam'.

It became a wake-up call to moderate Muslims in the country who believed Islamic fundamentalism existed only on the fringe.

It was also a turning point for the country's moderate brand of Islam.

Some are concerned the current trajectorywill result in a more conservative Islamic country â€" similar to Iran's abandonment of secularism following the Islamic Revolution in 1978-1979, and the Islamic revival following Anwar Sadat's death in Egypt.

Those events saw both cultures shift away from secularism following a change of government, but Dr Fealy does not think Indonesia will follow the same path.

"At the moment, being a Muslim is quite a trendy thing to do particularly in the middle class," he said.

"While it's possible that sections of society will continue to grow more conservatively Islamic and intolerant … we should be careful about assuming that Indonesia will continue in some kind of inexorable Islamisation curve over the next 20 years."

Baby death following vaccine fatwa

Two children in headscarves getting their vaccine shots with police observing Photo: The rubella-measles vaccine was declared 'haram', but allowed by the MUI due to a lack of alternatives. (Flickr: CDC Global)

A baby in the Muslim-majority province of Jambi recently died from the rubella virus.

The mother contracted the disease during pregnancy, and her child was born with defects due to it.

It came after peak Islamic body Indonesian Ulama Council (MUI), released a fatwa saying the vaccine for measles-rubella contained 'haram' substances.

The council said it contained traces of pork and human cells, which are religiously forbidden.

While they still allowed its use due to the importance of the vaccine, the decree reportedly hindered immunisation drives in Muslim-majority provinces.

Aman Pulungan, president of the Indonesian Paediatric Society, said it was a matter of great urgency.

"The main issue is a lack of access to the vaccines, which has been made complicated by involving religion," he said.

"The timing for the fatwa has definitely posed a hindrance."

Political tool or a shift to the 'right'?

Indonesian President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo, center left, speaks as his running mate Ma'ruf Amin, center right, listens. Photo: The battle lines for Indonesia's 2019 presidential election were drawn as Jokowi (L) chose his running mate (R). (AP: Tatan Syuflana)

Mr Widodo's decision to select Ma'ruf Amin, a hard-line Islamic cleric, as his running mate has seen him face criticism that he may be conceding to conservative Islamic forces.

Independent voter surveyor Poll Tracking Indonesia found more than 58 per cent of Indonesian voters take into account the religious credentials of the presidential and vice-presidential candidates.

With the 2019 presidential elections looming, analysts have said the race has become a question of who is "more Muslim".

"In the educated middle class, there has been r esistance towards Ma'ruf Amin and a sense of disappointment," Mr Naipospos said.

Jokowi's inability to protect his former ally, Ahok, in 2017 has exposed the Government's apparent vulnerability to mass political movements under the banner of Islam.

Meanwhile, his decision to ban a number of hard-line Islamist groups in response has fuelled opposition groups.

Who is General Prabowo?

The 66-year-old former lieutenant general has been connected to alleged human rights abuses during bloody military operations in Timor-Leste and Papua, as well as in Jakarta in 1998.

Dr Fealy said Jokowi's decision to choose Mr Amin was a political move aimed at removing the issue of religion as a potential vulnerability.

"Jokowi doesn't bring Islam into the political realm … he's never tried to use [religion] t o get an advantage over his opponent," he said.

"By contrast, [Opposition Leader] Prabowo Subianto is from a religiously plural family and he's not particularly Islamic … however, he has a long history of using religion for political purposes.

"The reality is that in the presidential elections next year, we have two figures who don't have all that high Islamic credibility by themselves."

Indonesia has never had a president, or vice-presidential candidate who was not a Muslim â€" highlighting the close relationship between the religion and politics.

Mr Naispospos thinks the relationship between religion and politics in Indonesia will continue to strengthen in the foreseeable future, but he remains hopeful Indonesia's future will still be one of its own brand of secularism.

"The issue of religion and politics [in Indonesia] is always dynamic," he said.

"One moment, religion can be stro nger than politics, but that pendulum can swing."

Topics: religion-and-beliefs, community-and-society, religious-leaders, government-and-politics, world-politics, indonesia, asia

First posted September 09, 2018 05:04:54

Source: Google News Indonesia | Netizen 24 Indonesia

Next
« Prev Post
Previous
Next Post »